Forgot password?
 Register account
View 263|Reply 6

[几何] Klein bottle contains Möbius band

[Copy link]

3156

Threads

7923

Posts

610K

Credits

Credits
64196
QQ

Show all posts

hbghlyj Posted 2023-3-2 06:55 |Read mode
A simple closed curve $C$ in a space $X$ is the image of a continuous injection $S^1→X$. Find simple closed curves $C_1, C_2$ and $C_3$ in the Klein bottle $K$ such that
  • $K∖C_1$ has one component, which is homeomorphic to an open annulus $S^1×(0,1)$.
  • $K∖C_2$ has one component, which is homeomorphic to an open Möbius band.
  • $K∖C_3$ has two components, each of which is homeomorphic to an open Möbius band.
[An open Möbius band is the space obtained from $[0,1] \times(0,1)$ by identifying $(0, y)$ with $(1,1-y)$ for each $y \in(0,1)$.]

3156

Threads

7923

Posts

610K

Credits

Credits
64196
QQ

Show all posts

 Author| hbghlyj Posted 2023-3-2 06:57

part (b)

Last edited by hbghlyj 2023-3-4 20:54If Klein bottle is cut along the dashed curve $C$
(it is closed curve because 4 corners are identified)

$K\setminus C$ has 1 component:

We can shift the right part to the left (as points are identified, this gives the same space):

This is a Möbius band. So part (b) is solved.

3156

Threads

7923

Posts

610K

Credits

Credits
64196
QQ

Show all posts

 Author| hbghlyj Posted 2023-3-2 07:28

part (a)

Last edited by hbghlyj 2023-3-4 21:03If Klein bottle is cut along the dashed curve $C$
(it is closed curve because 4 corners are identified)

$K\setminus C$ has 1 component:

We can rotate the upper part 180° and stick to the lower (as points are identified, this gives the same space):

This is homeomorphic to an open annulus $S^1×(0,1)$.

3156

Threads

7923

Posts

610K

Credits

Credits
64196
QQ

Show all posts

 Author| hbghlyj Posted 2023-3-2 08:05

part b) second solution

Last edited by hbghlyj 2023-3-4 21:11math.stackexchange.com/questions/1039875
can cut the Klein Bottle along the red edge (in reverse, a Möbius band becomes Klein Bottle when the two red edges are identified).

part a) second solution

can cut the Klein Bottle along the blue edge (in reverse, a cylinder becomes Klein Bottle when the two blue edges are identified).

48

Threads

771

Posts

110K

Credits

Credits
13880
QQ

Show all posts

Czhang271828 Posted 2023-3-2 13:23
Here is a short-cut to understand why Klein bottle contains Möbius band:

(1) Klein bottle = Möbius band + quotient relation on its boundary,

(2) There is another Möbius band properly contained in a given Möbius band.

Therefore, Klein bottle contains Möbius band.

3156

Threads

7923

Posts

610K

Credits

Credits
64196
QQ

Show all posts

 Author| hbghlyj Posted 2023-3-2 22:00

part b) third solution

Last edited by hbghlyj 2023-3-4 22:16Cutting vertically in the middle

we get 2 Möbius bands

3156

Threads

7923

Posts

610K

Credits

Credits
64196
QQ

Show all posts

 Author| hbghlyj Posted 2023-3-5 03:57

part c)

$C$ is the dashed curve (it is closed curve because 4 corners are identified, and midpoints of opposite sides are identified)
$K∖C$ is the shaded region:

$K∖C$ has only 2 components because the right edge is glued to the left edge:
Each is homeomorphic to a Möbius band.

Mobile version|Discuz Math Forum

2025-6-5 18:56 GMT+8

Powered by Discuz!

× Quick Reply To Top Edit